Q&A: Need Help Selecting Princess Cut Diamond with Matching Side Stones

Let me start by saying the website is phenomenal. The whole diamond buying experience can be so overwhelming and the information you provide helps reduce much of the anxiety. I’m looking to propose soon to my live in girl friend of 10 years and have decided on pricess cut stones in this setting:
https://www.jamesallen.com/design-your-three-stone-ring/three-stone-princess-cut-engagement-rings.html.
I wanted to have larger and different colored side stones than the ones James Allen provides in this setting. After speaking with a customer service representative they said I could pick all 3 stones myself or have them pick the 2 side stones and then I could choose the middle stone. This would lower the cost of the setting initially and would leave me with a budget for all 3 stones of $6500-$7000. I wanted the side stones to be 1/2 carat and then get as large as middle stone as possible and still stay within my budget(best value/best stone). After reading your information on princess cut stones I would be looking for eye-clean VS2, I-H colored. Do you think I should allow James Allen to pick my side stones or should I do it myself? Also, with side stones is there a specific size the middle stone should be? Any advice with regards to the individual stones would be greatly appreciated. Thanks so much and I look forward to you response.

Thanks for the fast response, Ira. I have several questions if you don’t mind. Should I be concerned that 1 of the side stones is of higher quality color than the center stone (H v I)? And should I be concerned about not seeing a picture of the center stone? I really do appreciate the time and effort you’ve taken in this matter. I’ve been with Tami for a long time and want everything to be as perfect as possible (within reason). The stones you’ve suggested are right in my price range and exactly what I had in mind size wise. Thanks again for all your help.

Thanks, Ira. Great advice. I’ll be calling James Allen shortly and placing the stones on hold. Would you mind checking out the photo when it becomes available? Good to hear you have a Tami too!

The picture of the stone finally uploaded today. What do you think?
https://www.jamesallen.com/diamonds/I-VS2-Ideal-Cut-Princess-Diamond-1361739.asp

I’m in! Thanks again for all your help, Ira.
…….
I just wanted to let you know I got engaged this weekend and the ring looked fabulous. Thank you so much for the help you provided picking out the diamonds. She was shocked and very impressed with the ring. You’re the man!

No problem. Consider it done.
[LINK TO REVIEW ON IVOUCH]